A Mock Congress Debates Proposed Laws
Posted Date: 11/17/26 (03:40 PM)
Carmel High School students got a firsthand look at how laws are made by stepping into the roles of lawmakers, advocates and voters.After learning about the legislative branch and the process of turning a bill into law, 11th grade U.S. History students were divided into committees and assigned issues to research and debate. Topics included lowering the legal drinking age to 18, gun control, abortion and the death penalty. Each committee researched its assigned issue, examined the arguments and presented three points to support its position. After the presentations, classmates joined the discussion and students cast their votes.

During one session in teacher Kerry Hackert’s class, 11th-graders Sylvia and Violet took the podium to argue in favor of lowering the legal drinking age to 18. They pointed out that 18-year-olds can vote, serve in the military and live independently from their parents."They are already entrusted with important responsibilities, so they should also be able to decide what to drink," Sylvia said. "Plus, being able to drink in a public setting is safer because you can do it with adults around."

Violet offered an economic argument."It's also a way to boost the economy," she said, pointing to the high taxes collected on alcohol.
Students on the opposing committee raised concerns about the dangers of lowering the drinking age, including that it would give younger teenagers easier access to alcohol."They are in high school with 18-year-olds and could ask them to buy the alcohol," Lucas said. "But most 14-year-olds don't hang out with 21-year-olds, who are already in college."
Safety was another point of discussion."Most people get their driver's license at 16," Lucas said. "Lowering the drinking age to 18 could cause more car crashes if inexperienced drivers also drink."After hearing both sides and taking part in the debate, the class cast its vote. The final tally was nine in favor of lowering the drinking age and 11 opposed. But that was just the vote of one class. In other periods of the same class, Ms. Hackert said, students voted in favor of lowering the drinking age. 
